Showing posts with label Alfie Kohn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alfie Kohn. Show all posts

Thursday, January 23, 2014

Sorry Friedman, YOU Missed the Point



My Op-Ed review of Friedman's Op-Ed

I just read Thomas Friedman's article entitled Obama's Homework Assignment from Sunday's NY Times and didn't agree with most of it.  It may hold some truth in districts where kids are highly underprivileged and parents need to care a bit more about their kid's education, but in middle to upper income school districts I feel that kind of article would exacerbate many of the problems I see here in the Tri-Valley every day.  Friedman's type of logic keeps kids on the Race to Nowhere, spinning their wheels to get into colleges that only a small % will get into anyway, and following traditional definitions of success.  

We have to redefine success.  Friedmann seems to believe success is about high achieving kids, high test scores, and comparing ourselves to other countries - all of which can be accomplished by super-hero teachers and super involved, demanding parents.  Those performance-driven definitions of success lead to many of the problems he speaks of in the first place.  

The irony is that if kids were taught differently (by teachers and parents), where intrinsic motivation, creativity, problem-solving, and cooperation ruled, then all the other stuff would fall into place and test scores and high performance probably WOULD go up.  But demanding more of our already over-scheduled kids, or, expecting all teachers to be uber-incredible, or, yelling at our kids about how much time they spend on screens is not where our energies should lie.  Let's embrace their new tools and interests, let's look at them as people and not just as performers and work together with them (asking their advice) about how to improve education, one small, unique idea at a time.  Teachers and parents should be the supportive Guide on the Side, not the Sage on the Stage, as Alfie Kohn so aptly puts it.

Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Too Much Homework?



I've been asked by many parents through the years what they should do if they feel their child's homework load is excessive.  It's a tough question to answer because there is no one answer.  And, really, that's why I started this blog, to be a resource for parents, teachers and students who were struggling with issues of quality and quantity of homework.

I suggest you start with this article called
Homework: How Much Is Too Much.

This informative article gives you suggestions about how to talk to teachers about homework expectations, it mentions the 10-minute/grade level rule, it gives great book suggestions, it opens a dialogue for an opt-out policy, it gives a sample school district homework policy guideline, it suggests healthy ways kids can spend their time NOT doing homework.

You have to do your own homework to deal with this issue.  Sadly, there is no one, quick solution, so I suggest you read this article, and start here.

My journey with this issue began when I read The Homework Myth by Alfie Kohn and had an informal discussion with friends about it.  I also found the website Stop Homework by Sara Bennett.  The good news is that in the six years I've been reading and writing about this subject, much awareness has been brought to this topic. Dig around my blog a little and you will find a multitude of resources to help you in your grassroots effort to re-think established homework norms.

I have so many excellent resources listed on my blue sidebar on the right side of this blog.  Check out: Homework ArticlesHomework DVDs and AudioBooks on Homework.

Your journey has already begun by finding my blog!  Pass it on to others who also struggle with this topic.

And, feel free to leave comments.

Friday, June 7, 2013

End of Year Teacher Gift Idea

Why not give the gift of a book to a teacher as the school year winds down?  Click here for my suggestions on books about homework.

My three favorites from this list are:

The Homework Myth by Alfie Kohn


The Case Against Homework by Sara Bennett and Nancy Kalish


The above two books are parent-friendly and this one is more teacher-friendly:




I happen to have 2 copies of Rethinking Homework for my local friends.  If you would like to buy one from me, please email me at KerryTeegen@gmail.com.  The cost is $10.00.










Monday, July 9, 2012

Spoiled or Special?



Check out this recent article by Elizabeth Kolbert in The New Yorker: "Spoiled Rotten: Why Do Kids Rule the Roost?"


Some highlights from this article:

  • "With the exception of the imperial offspring of the Ming dynasty and the dauphins of pre-Revolutionary France, contemporary American kids may represent the most indulged young people in the history of the world. It’s not just that they’ve been given unprecedented amounts of stuff—clothes, toys, cameras, skis, computers, televisions, cell phones, PlayStations, iPods. (The market for Burberry Baby and other forms of kiddie “couture” has reportedly been growing by ten per cent a year.) They’ve also been granted unprecedented authority. “Parents want their kids’ approval, a reversal of the past ideal of children striving for their parents’ approval,” Jean Twenge and W. Keith Campbell, both professors of psychology, have written."

  • "After four years in college and two on the West Coast, her son Jed moved back to Manhattan and settled into his old room in the family’s apartment, together with thirty-four boxes of vinyl LPs. Unemployed, Jed liked to stay out late, sleep until noon, and wander around in his boxers. Koslow set out to try to understand why he and so many of his peers seemed stuck in what she regarded as permanent “adultescence.” She concluded that one of the reasons is the lousy economy."

  • “'The best way for a lot of us to show our love would be to learn to un-mother and un-father.' One practical tip ... is to do nothing when your adult child finally decides to move out." 

  • "Also key, Druckerman discovered, is just saying non. In contrast to American parents, French parents, when they say it, actually mean it. They 'view learning to cope with ‘no’ as a crucial step in a child’s evolution,' Druckerman writes. 'It forces them to understand that there are other people in the world, with needs as powerful as their own.'”

  • "The cycle in American households seems mostly to run in the opposite direction. So little is expected of kids that even adolescents may not know how to operate the many labor-saving devices their homes are filled with."

  • "In A Nation of Wimps: The High Cost of Invasive Parenting (Broadway), Hara Estroff Marano argues that college rankings are ultimately to blame for what ails the American family. Her argument runs more or less as follows: High-powered parents worry that the economic opportunities for their children are shrinking. They see a degree from a top-tier school as one of the few ways to give their kids a jump on the competition. In order to secure this advantage, they will do pretty much anything, which means not just taking care of all the cooking and cleaning but also helping their children with math homework, hiring them S.A.T. tutors, and, if necessary, suing their high school." 

  • "In contemporary American culture, the patterns are more elusive. What values do we convey by turning our homes into warehouses for dolls? By assigning our kids chores and then rewarding them when they screw up? By untying and then retying their shoes for them? It almost seems as if we’re actively trying to raise a nation of 'adultescents.' And, perhaps without realizing it, we are."


Ouch!

So, how do you feel after reading this article? My thoughts are that I realize my boys have been given a lot of stuff and experiences in their lives that are unnecessary, and yet I've tried to teach them to not be materialistic despite all that they have, and all they have experienced. I've also tried to be an authoritative parent (not permissive and not authoritarian) - hoping to guide them while giving and receiving both respect and love. It's a continual work in progress, parenting in between indulgence and strict obedience.

Check out my side bar under Books on Parenting.  One recently published book to note is: Teach Your Children Well: Parenting for Authentic Success by Madeline Levine.  And, a favorite of mine that I read several times when my boys were younger: Unconditional Parenting: Moving from Rewards and Punishments to Love and Reason by Alfie Kohn.

Your thoughts on spoiled children or parenting?






Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Homework Guidelines and Reflection




Are you ready for a new vision on homework?

Today the “Race to Nowhere" Team, as well as education and homework experts Alfie Kohn, Sara Bennett and Etta Kralovec will be presenting new Healthy Homework Guidelines to the National PTA in hopes of gaining their endorsement.

To see a sneak peek of a video they’ll be playing for the PTA promoting a new vision for homework, go here.

I am on the Advisory Board for the film "Race to Nowhere" and I support Vicki Abeles' efforts to bring homework to the agenda of the National PTA.

As Alfie Kohn says in the video, "Homework may be the greatest single extinguisher of children's curiosity that we have yet invented."

I read Kohn's book "The Homework Myth" in 2007 when my oldest son was in 7th grade. A typically happy, fun kid who loved life and liked school, he became depressed and seriously stressed out in 7th grade. Much of that was due to a bad experience with a teacher, with a subject (math), and with homework that year. It isn't an exaggeration to say he hated school that year and he will tell you even today how horrible middle school was for him particularly in 7th grade.

That was the year I got together with another parent and we took our homework concerns to the district. It ultimately ended with a creation of a homework task force (which I was on) and a revision of the district's homework policy.

Are things better now in my son's school district with regard to homework quality and quantity? Hmmm...every teacher and every child and every situation is different, so there is no gross generalization I can make about this.

The main point I try to make to parents is: don't stress out about your children's homework and grades. Their homework is THEIR homework, not YOURS. If they don't understand an assignment, they need to ask the teacher. They need to advocate for themselves. It is not your job to teach your children their assignments or do their homework for them. You can offer assistance when they ask you, but only be on the sidelines. Don't take over their work.

I'm speaking to an educated group of parents that read this blog, who are very involved in their children's lives. Perhaps we need to be a bit less involved, and let them take more ownership of their own activities and school work? Perhaps it's time to NOT stress about our children's academics and performance, but instead reflect on their spirit, goodness, character and playfulness- to enjoy their childhood before it is gone.


Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Two in the Middle


I recently received this email and wanted to share it with my blog readers.  I applaud Pamela's efforts to do something creative, effective, productive and loving for her daughter.  Please read her story:


Dear Kerry,

I so admire the effort you have put into changing the way your school district looks at homework.  I know you wish it were even better, but what you accomplished was huge.

Alfie Kohn's book The Homework Myth gave my UCLA professor husband and I the courage to reconsider the importance of having any homework during 7th and 8th grade, when we home-schooled our daughter.  When our daughter Natalie arrived home each day from her 6th grade class (where the focus was preparing the children for middle school) looking as depleted as the most overworked adult we knew, we made a bold decision.  We decided to jump off the stress wagon to help her rediscover the joy of learning and healthy living.   By home schooling for two years, our daughter was able to wholeheartedly delve into subjects, which included not only history and math, but also music, dance and gardening.   She did not have homework, although she read every night for pleasure, which I know expanded her vocabulary better than vocabulary lists and quizzes.  By the end of 8thgrade, she was totally prepared for high school, and all of us were healthier and happier.   And we purposely chose a high school with a healthy homework policy.  I've recently completed a memoir about our adventure, which I hope will be published sooner than later.  You might like to visit my website: Two in the Middle 


Best regards,
Pamela

Thursday, May 5, 2011

STAR Testing


We are in the midst of STAR testing now in our school district. I invite readers to go back to my earlier post on STAR testing here. If you get a chance to read it, please also see the comments that followed that post.

I see a lot of time spent on preparation for tests in our high achieving district. This year one of my son's teachers gave a practice, graded STAR test. I felt that was a waste of my son's time. Instead I would have preferred his teacher to continue teaching the content.

As Alfie Kohn says in his new book Feel-Bad Education

"The more time spent teaching students how to do well on a particular test -- familiarizing them with its content and format -- the less meaningful the results of that test. What those results mostly tell us is how well students were prepared for that test, not what knowledge and skills they have in general."



Thursday, September 16, 2010

Being Happy & Raising Happy Kids

I recently read “Raising Happiness” by Christine Carter, Ph.D. and have highlighted some of my favorite quotes below. And, I also came across a video from University of Michigan professor Christopher Peterson, an expert in “positive psychology” that compliments this book nicely. If you want to watch the video it is about 5 minutes long.

Here are quotes from Raising Happiness:

"The most important work you and I will ever do will be within the walls of our own homes. —HAROLD B. LEE

Anxiety & Stress:

Anxiety in mothers … is associated with increased anxiety in children.

According to … The Lucile Packard Foundation for Children’s Health, only about half of parents rate their children’s overall emotional and behavioral health as excellent, and 67 percent worry that their teens are too stressed.

Research shows that living in high-stress environments corresponds with a poor ability to delay gratification.

Success:

Nothing has a stronger influence psychologically … on children than the unlived life of the parent. —CARL JUNG

Even if you prioritize your children’s success over their happiness, here is why you should read this book: happiness is a tremendous advantage in a world that emphasizes performance. On average, happy people are more successful than unhappy people at both work and love.

All we have to do is clearly send the message that effort is more important than achievement. When we define success as how hard kids try rather than what kind of grades they get or whether they win the game, we foster the growth mind-set.

Optimism & Gratitude:

Realize that true happiness lies within you. Waste no time and effort searching for peace and contentment and joy in the world outside. Remember that there is no happiness in having or in getting, but only in giving… —OG MANDINO

parents who tend to explain things optimistically tend to have kids who mimic their explanatory styles—as humans, we’re wired for mimicry.

create some alone time to begin a gratitude journal. Writing about things you feel grateful for is a simple way to bring more joy into your life.

ForGIVEness is an act of kindness and generosity—toward ourselves and others. Similarly, an expression of gratitude is a gift, a sometimes tiny but often powerful and generous expression of positive feeling.

Start traditions that celebrate people on their birthdays—not toys and cake and balloons—such as telling the story of a child’s birth, or having everyone at a party complete the sentence “I’m happy you were born because …”

Marriage:

The two main things we need to do, Gottman says, are (1) handle conflict in a positive manner and (2) become better friends.

the way you fight with your co-parent is how your teenager is most likely to fight with you. If you resolve conflicts by becoming angry, so too will your adolescent. On the other hand, if you engage in more constructive problem solving, your teen is likely to mimic that as well.

If you can’t resolve the argument in front of the kids, be sure to demonstrate later that the relationship has been repaired, show them that you’ve reconnected, and tell them how the conflict was resolved.

“Children are great perceivers but poor interpreters.” Kids feel it deeply when their parents fight or when they are unhappy themselves.

When kids see us resolve our differences, and when they see us take charge of our own well-being, they learn skills that will serve them well for a lifetime.

Happiness:

If I had to pick the one thing that matters most to human happiness, I would say that our relationships with other people matter more than anything else.

So there is a lot that we can do to ensure our children’s happiness—and our own at the same time. In fact, there is a perpetual “buy one, get one free” special: teach your kids the skills they need to be happy, and you’ll become happier yourself in the process.

psychologist David Myers concludes that “there are few stronger predictors of happiness than a close, nurturing, equitable, intimate, lifelong companionship with one’s best friend.”

How well children establish relationships with other people greatly affects their happiness in childhood and later in life. … But kids who develop strong relationships and are socially intelligent—as emotional intelligence guru Daniel Goleman calls it—tend to flourish.

Happy people have different decision-making processes than unhappy people; they tend to satisfice. Maximizing is tempting for perfectionists, and it is associated with unhappiness and discontent.

When we teach children the road signs that point to happiness, we tend to find ourselves taking those same roads as well.

Because to be really happy in life—to flourish, as Fredrickson calls it—we need to experience three or more positive feelings for every negative one.

His Holiness, the Dalai Lama said, “You will need to get a job and find a partner. These are hard tasks. Even if you don’t want it to be, life is difficult. You will have problems and challenges. But even though life is difficult, it is possible to be happy.”

Communication/Conflict Resolution:

practice eye contact with our kids: studies show that eye contact opens our neural pathways for empathy.

if our faces and tone of voice say “I love you,” even when what we are literally saying might be hard to hear, our kids are likely to still feel okay about the interaction.

Effective conflict resolution requires empathy: kids have to be able to take their friends’ or siblings’ points of view into account, which presents a natural opportunity for children to learn to consider other people’s feelings.

Altruism/Empathy:

Kinder people actually live longer, healthier lives. People who volunteer tend to experience fewer aches and pains.

Adolescents who identify their primary motive as helping others are three times happier than those who lack such altruistic motivation.

The key word here is empathetic; it works better to help kids imagine the emotions of those they are helping: “I think we should share with poor children, because they would be so happy and excited if they had the money to buy food and toys. After all, poor children have almost nothing. If everyone would help these children, maybe they wouldn’t look so sad.”

Added bonus: when we expose kids to others’ suffering, they often feel compassion and gratitude.

Rewards & Motivation:

Don’t reward helping behavior. Very young children who receive material rewards for helping others become less likely to engage in further helping compared with toddlers who receive only verbal praise or no reward at all. This research suggests that even the youngest children are intrinsically motivated, and extrinsic rewards can undermine this tendency.

The more we parents can stay in our role as coaches—holding back all of our terrific (bossy!) ideas and letting kids come up with their own—the better. The best ideas come from the kids themselves, when they explore the problem from their own perspective and knowledge.

I call it ERNing, or motivating kids through Empathy, Reason, and Noncontrolling language. Before, I was motivating them to earn a reward; now I motivate them with ERN encouragement.

Instead of trying to motivate kids with rewards and incentives, we parents sometimes need to back off so that kids can work on the creative activities that they’re intrinsically motivated to do.

Fathers:

The best predictor of a dad’s involvement is the quality of his relationship with his children’s mother (whether or not they are married). If a marriage or a co-parenting relationship is fraught with conflict, fathers tend to have a difficult time being involved with their children, which of course weakens the father-child relationship. Good fathering can also strengthen a marriage. Fathers who are positively involved in their children’s lives are significantly more likely to have successful marriages.

Praise & Effort:

When we send the message to our kids that their talents are inborn—as when we tell them that they are a “natural baseball player” or “good at math”—we create an urgency in them to prove their “gifts” over and over. It isn’t that kids don’t like this praise: they do. It puffs them up and even encourages them to keep doing whatever it is they are doing. Unfortunately, when kids want to keep their special label as talented, they also start to avoid learning new things, and they start choosing activities based on whether or not they think they will succeed or fail, look smart or dumb, be accepted or rejected.

But knowing that it is practice rather than innate talent that makes a person successful can help kids take risks to rise to the top of their field—or to try something new in order to find their true passion.

Besides making them insecure and crushing the fun of learning something new, telling kids how smart they are actually hinders performance. On the other hand, the effort-praised kids continued to have fun even when they weren’t doing as well.

Achievements:

As parents put more and more pressure on their children to achieve, more and more children become perfectionists. Sometimes parents’ well-intentioned perfectionism emerges more subtly, as when we try to help kids by pointing out their mistakes in ways that make our kids feel judged and criticized. Kids conclude that they’re never good enough or can’t do anything on their own without us helping them.

Ironically, focusing on kids’ short-term achievements can prevent them from achieving more in the long term.

When kids do something quickly and perfectly, Dweck recommends saying to them: “Whoops! I guess that was too easy. I apologize for wasting your time. Let’s do something you can really learn from!”

when parents show kids that they aren’t personally invested in whether they make the team or ace the test or get into an elite college—they free their children from the fixed mindset.

Failure:

We need to protect our kids not from failure but from a life void of failure.

All we can do is help our kids with their approach and send the message that, while we expect their full commitment and solid effort, we’re also okay with their mistakes and their fumbles.

The gist of Schwartz’s research is that having a lot of choice is a curse on our happiness. Knowing this makes me feel better about restricting the choices my kids have. And I no longer think of myself as settling when I make a decision without exploring all the options. I’m modeling satisficing for my kids; and if they pick up on it, they’ll be happier in the long run.

Grit is also a core component of lifelong happiness. When kids learn that they can’t cope with life’s difficulties—because mom or dad always seems so eager to make sure that they never occur, and because mom and dad are always solving kids’ problems—the kids come to fear challenge. Mistakes become something to be avoided at all costs. This can create perfectionistic tendencies, which, …, are a particular form of unhappiness.

Anger:

Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one getting burned. —BUDDHA

So a big part of forgiveness is the decision to stop thinking about the offense and start directing our energy toward finding a way to forgive.

Play:

unstructured and imaginative playtime builds executive function in kids, an important cognitive skill related to self-regulation.

Researchers concluded that the decline in the amount of time kids “practiced playing”…was responsible for this decline in their ability to self-regulate.

child-led, unstructured play (with or without adults) promotes intellectual, physical, social, and emotional well-being. Unstructured play helps children learn how to work in groups, to share, negotiate, resolve conflicts, regulate their emotions and behavior, and speak up for themselves.

Play is a catalyst that makes us more productive and happier in everything we do. And it is critical for children’s brain development. So we driven parents need to curb our impulses to sacrifice good old-fashioned play in favor of preschool academics and structured sports.

If you notice yourself frowning, sighing, or rolling your eyes when your children aren’t playing the way you want them to, take a step back and let them run the show.

Children who engage in more pretend play with peers tend to demonstrate a greater understanding of other kids’ emotions.

Increased emotional intelligence and social skills contribute dramatically to children’s school success. Play increases the odds that kids will be persistent and stay engaged in difficult classroom tasks, helping them become more involved learners.

Fantasy play expands kids’ cognitive and behavioral repertoires, leading to more highly developed creativity, divergent thinking, and cooperative problem-solving skills.

Punishment:

Like being psychologically controlling, punitive parenting wreaks havoc on children’s ability to discipline themselves.

deprivation of privileges and corporal punishment—social science has built a clear body of evidence that shows that these techniques are ultimately ineffective and certainly undesirable for those interested in raising happy children.

As Alfie Kohn says, “Don’t move a child roughly if you can move her gently; don’t move her gently if you can tell her to move; don’t tell her if you can ask her.”

Day Care:

High-quality care makes your child more likely to have higher standardized math, reading, and memory scores, but only through the third grade. By the time kids are about eleven, the only lasting academic benefit of high-quality care is relatively higher vocabulary scores.

We do know that the more time that kids spend in nonmaternal care relative to their peers, the more likely they will be rated by their teachers and caregivers as talking, bragging, and arguing too much, disobedient and defiant, talking out of turn and talking back to staff, and otherwise disruptive in school, aggressive: more likely to get into fights; be cruel, bullying, or mean; and be destructive to their own belongings

Child psychologists and education specialists have repeatedly found that kids who devote more time to complex pretend play before grade school age (versus kids who spend a lot of time in structured or caregiver-directed activities) are more likely to be cognitively and socially competent with peers and adults.

Kids in child-focused schools, rather than in didactic programs that spend more time teaching academic skills directly, show more motivation at school.

So while didactic preschool programs do improve kids’ scores on reading (but not math) achievement tests, they can kill kids’ love of learning.

Family Meals:

The benefits of family mealtimes for kids are remarkable. Studies show that kids who eat dinner with their families on a regular basis are more emotionally stable and less likely to abuse drugs and alcohol. They get better grades. They have fewer depressive symptoms, particularly among adolescent girls. And they are less likely to become obese or have an eating disorder. Family dinners even trump reading to your kids in terms of preparing them for school."


The author of “Raising Happiness” was interviewed in Diablo magazine and you can check that out here.

Any thoughts on happiness or any other comments?


Friday, May 21, 2010

3 Observations on Homework

1. If homework can be copied, it is bad homework.

Most kids will cheat on homework if they can. Why not? It usually feels like a waste of their time, especially if the teacher just checks it off and doesn’t give constructive feedback on it.

What kind of homework can be cheated on? Fill in the blanks, word searches, crossword puzzles, end of chapter summaries, math problems, etc.

What kind of homework cannot be copied or done by someone else for you? Reading for pleasure, personal journal entries, & studying for a quiz or test.

What kind of homework is good homework? Homework that turns the students on to whatever it is they are learning. This could include just about any type of homework, but typically it will involve: working on something of interest to the student that they can do on their own (or with a classmate) that they have plenty of time to complete, like a really creative, student-driven project. This may also include reading for pleasure (if they enjoy reading) and writing for pleasure (if they enjoy writing).

But how will a teacher know if a student understands material if she doesn’t give worksheets and chapter summaries? Instructional devices like work sheets, writing and reading exercises, and discussions are formative assessments teachers should use during class time. These learning activities are practice for students and will help the teacher evaluate her instruction. If these activities come home as homework, the teacher doesn’t have a true gauge of the student’s learning because someone else can do the work for the student. See this article: “To Grade or Not to Grade Homework”

2. If homework must be given, make it the exception, not the rule, and please make it creative.

If teachers occasionally must assign homework, it should be teacher designed (not copied out of a text book or a work sheet).

This tip is from one of Alfie Kohn’s articles: “Changing the Homework Default”

Assign only what you design. In most cases, students should be asked to do only what teachers are willing to create themselves, as opposed to prefabricated worksheets or generic exercises photocopied from textbooks. Also, it rarely makes sense to give the same assignment to all students in a class because it’s unlikely to be beneficial for most of them. Those who already understand the concept will be wasting their time, and those who don’t understand will become increasingly frustrated. There is no perfect assignment that will stimulate every student because one size simply doesn’t fit all. On those days when homework really seems necessary, teachers should create several assignments fitted to different interests and capabilities. But it’s better to give no homework to anyone than the same homework to everyone."

3. If homework must be given, do NOT grade it.

Students tell me they must do their homework because they cannot lose points. What is wrong with this statement? Wouldn’t it be ideal if students said they had to do their homework because otherwise they wouldn’t understand something they were supposed to be learning in school? Or, better yet, that they wanted to do their homework because it was so interesting to them and they were really getting excited about something they were learning in school.

When teachers make homework about points and grades, the emphasis on learning disappears and students begin to focus on grades instead of the content of the subject. Additionally, “of all student work, homework assignments are the most likely to receive zeros. The accumulation of zeros can unfairly skew the total grade far below the total grade as indicated by tests. And, the effects of zeros on beginning learners can place many dangerously at-risk. Failure does not motivate, but frustrates and discourages.”

Read more at Suite101: To Grade or Not to Grade Homework: Homework is for Diagnosis and Practice http://skill-assessment.suite101.com/article.cfm/homework_to_grade_or_not_to_grade#ixzz0obxKE7uk

Your thoughts on any of these 3 homework observations?

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Tales of a 4th Grade Homework Assignment


I received this from a parent of a 4th grader the other day. This was the homework assignment one night for her child:

“Math 8-7 We never actually did work pages in class, so a review of the

lesson is probably going to be necessary before the quiz is taken. We did a

lot of hands on activities instead.

Reading literature book chapters 15-19 - book chat with buddy tomorrow

Writing - final copy of persuasive speech so practice of speech can happen

in front of the mirror to know what bullet points should go on 5 x 8 card

for Thursday/Friday presentation of snowman.”

If you asked many different parents and teachers their opinions of these assignments, I bet you would get many different responses ranging from – “this seems reasonable” to “this seems ridiculous.”

When I look at homework assignments two things come to mind. How long will it take my child to complete the homework, and is this homework really helping him learn or get excited about the things he is learning at school?

The first issue (time limits and quantity of homework) can be discussed with teachers. Even though many teachers will say that each child is different, and what takes one child 30 minutes to complete may take another child 3 hours, this doesn't have to be the end of the discussion.

As a parent, if you find yourself in a conference, phone call or email with a teacher discussing a situation where your child spends too much time on homework, be prepared for the above answer and have your response ready.

My suggestion is that you mention all of the other things your child could be spending his time on instead of homework – chores, cooking, play, reading for fun, walking the dog, sleep, sports, music, art, downtime, etc. – that are as important to your family as homework (or more important!).

Also arm yourself with the knowledge of your district’s homework policy and mention the time guideline to your child’s teacher if your child is regularly spending more time on homework than the policy suggests. Chances are the time limit issue can be somewhat resolved if the teacher is willing to work out an arrangement with you.

But, the bigger question here is – is this homework helping my child learn and/or get excited about what he/she is learning at school? So, this becomes as issue of quality of homework and teaching. And, unfortunately, there’s no easy way to talk to teachers about this. But, that doesn't mean you can't try.

In the above homework example it looks as if the teacher wants the parents to teach the math lesson to the child even though he says it’s a “review” yet he admits that they never actually did the pages in class. He also says they did a lot of “hands on” activities in class. This sounds like he is asking the parents to do the boring work at home with the kids because they only have time for the interesting activities in class.

What would you do in this situation? I would ask my 4th grade child what he did in math class that day and see if he retained anything from the activities. If he remembered the lesson, then he’s done and ready for the quiz, if not, I’d send the teacher an email politely saying that he didn’t remember the math lesson and would he/she mind re-teaching it? I would also politely ask the teacher if he/she routinely expects the parents to teach what he/she doesn’t have time to cover in class. If the answer is “yes,” then I’d send an email to the principal with my concerns.

In addition to this math work, the 4th grade child also had 5 chapters of reading due (in a book that was teacher selected), writing a final copy of a persuasive speech and practicing it, and working on a presentation for another day. It sounds like it will take most 4th graders more than the National PTA endorsed limit of 40 minutes for 4th graders to complete. And where is the time alloted for reading for pleasure?

The parent of this child told me that her other child, who is a senior in high school, regularly has less homework than her 4th grader!

So what else can you do as a parent when you see your child doing homework for too long, or doing homework that is uninspired or busywork? Arm yourself with the latest research on homework. There are many homework books and articles listed on my sidebar that are full of relevant information on homework for parents and teachers. Here's a quick link from The Case Against Homework: http://stophomework.com/fact.pdf And here's an article from Alfie Kohn's website: Rethinking Homework. Or, send your teacher a link to my blog. Or, ask your teacher if they've seen the documentary Race to Nowhere.

Share these books and facts with others and keep talking with other parents. Once you’ve exhausted yourself talking with other parents, start having conversations with the teachers about your concerns. Even a polite email can do the trick. Or, a telephone conversation or conference is even better than email. Or, buy one of the homework books listed on this blog and give them to your child's teacher as a gift. It may spark a debate at school and get teachers to re-think accepted homework practices.

Ask other parents in your child's classes how they feel. If more than a couple of you feel the same about a homework assignment or teaching practice, have each of you email the teacher. One email about a particular homework issue can be ignored, but five emails from five different families about the same issue make an impact.

Sometimes, unfortunately, teachers become defensive when you approach them with homework concerns. When this happens, don't give up. It is okay to respectfully disagree and use that experience as a learning lesson to better prepare yourself for your next discussion with an educator.